Monday, 3 October 2011
FC Barcelona: 4-3-3 or 3-4-3?
4-3-3 only describes the defensive system that Barça use when they need to defend. However, 3-4-3 describes an attacking line-up. In reality when Barça have to defend they always seek to get their players into a 4-3-3 formation. This is important as Barça are a very attack minded team and tend to dominate possession of the ball. What is crucial then is how the team is aligned at the moment when they lose possession of the ball. For this is when the team is most vulnerable to a counter attack.
It is therefore better to compare the two attacking line-ups that Barça tend to use. In this case 4-3-3 becomes much more a 2-3-2-3 line-up. While 3-4-3 is more accurately described as a 3-1-2-1-3 system. From this it is obvious that the so-called 4-3-3 line-up as actually as practised by Barça is the more risky option. With this system, when the team lose possession they only have two defenders in place, while with the other system they always have three defenders in place. In other words, 3-4-3 is the more secure defensively.
It may be easier to appreciate the difference if we put names to the line-ups. First the traditional 4-3-3 or more accurately, 2-3-2-3 system. Recently this has featured the following players, starting from the back.
Abidal Villa
Piqué Iniesta
Busquets Messi
Mascheranno Xavi
Alves Pedro
When the team lose the ball, Abidal and Alves move back to form a back four with Piqué and Mascheranno, while Iniesta and Xavi also move back to line up alongside Busquets, thus creating the traditional 4-3-3 defensive set-up.
Now for the 3-4-3 or 3-1-2-1-3 system. This is how it looks with the following players, again starting from the back.
Abidal Villa
Iniesta
Mascheranno Busquets Fàbregas Messi
Xavi
Alves Pedro
In this case, when Barça lose the ball, Busquets would try to get back as quickly as possible to join the back three, while Fàbregas would also move back to play alongside Xavi and Iniesta. Once again the team is organized in their traditional defensive 4-3-3 set-up.
So, as far as I can see, the so-called 3-4-3 line-up is the more secure defensively, as the team always has three defenders in place. The other advantage is that the diamond shaped midfield allows Guardiola to play Fàbregas alongside Xavi and Iniesta. There would appear though to be two downsides to this system. One was shown in the first half of their away match against Valencia. There the home team attacked with skill, speed and numbers and caused Barça all kinds of problems and managed to score two goals. What this shows to me is that against some teams, Guardiola may have to use four defenders. The crucial point is that the two full backs have to stay back. In such a situation Barça's attacking line-up would be 4-1-2-3. The other possible weakness of 3-4-3 is that a lot seems to depend on the use of Fàbregas as the apex of the midfield diamond. His skill, movement and understanding with Messi has been one of the keys to Barça's attacking threat this season. Against Sporting, with Fàbregas injured, they tried Pedro in that role, with only limited success. I'm not sure who else in the squad can fulfil this role with the same effectiveness as Fàbregas. But it will be interesting to see if Guardiola sticks with this system while Cesc is out injured. As usual interesting times ahead for Barça.
Tuesday, 30 August 2011
FC Barcelona 2011-12 Even Better?
Monday, 4 July 2011
Barça Transfers - Is Anyone Coming?
Monday, 6 June 2011
Barça Transfer Rumours – Nothing but Hot Air?
Wednesday, 18 May 2011
FC Barcelona - what next for 2011/12?
Friday, 3 September 2010
FC Barcelona - the new season starts
This is very important for Barça, as Guardiola believes in running a very small first team squad. The current one has only 19 players, including the two goalkeepers. Which is a very tight group for such a long and possibly arduous season. However Guardiola prefers this as it makes for a more competitive squad in which everyone is guaranted to play a fair number of matches. In addition of course, Guardiola will call upon players from the B team to cover any real emergencies. Already some of these youngsters have played for the first team and a few of them will get their chance during the season. So look out for the likes of Jonathan dos Santos and Thiago Alcantara in midfield, and Sergi Gomez, Andrew Fontàs and Marc Bartras in defence.
Once again the main targets will be the league and the Champions League. How likely? It has to be said straight off that winning three league titles in a row is a very, very rare occurrence. It was last achieved in Spain by Johann Cruyff`s legendary Barcelona Dream Team, when they managed to win four in a row between 1991-1994. So an enormous task awaits them. Once again the main challenger, perhaps the only challenger will be Real Madrid. They will be desperate to prevent Barça from winning again and to this end they have not only signed lots of new players, but also a new coach in José Mourinho. Mourinho of course has a great record of winning league titles in Portugal, England and Italy, not to mention the odd Champions League as well. So Real will be hoping that he can repeat the magic at the Bernabéu. Not that even Mourinho will find this easy. Like last year he has to create a winning team from a large number of players, some of whom are very good. If anyone can one is tempted to say that Mourinho is the one to do it. It should certainly make for an exciting season.
As regards the Champions League, once again it is hard to see beyond the usual suspects, with Chelsea, Manchester United, Inter Milan as the most dangerous rivals. Silvio Berlusconi is spending big money again and AC Milan may also prove a real threat. And of course if Mourinho does manage to weave his magic, then Real Madrid will also be in there as real challengers.
All in all this is shaping up to be an exciting and enjoyable season. Particularly with the arrival of Villa, Barça should be an even greater goal scoring threat than last season and look fair to rival the triple winning team from 2009, at least in terms of goals scored. We will need to wait till next May to find out if they can also repeat the winning of titles. Visca Barça!
Thursday, 20 May 2010
FC Barcelona 2009-2010

This was always going to be a difficult season for Barça. The previous season they won all three major competitions - Spanish League and Cup and the Champions League. The first time any team had achieved this triple crown. Something almost impossible to repeat. So Barça did very well to retain one of their crowns from last season - the Spanish League. And they did so with style, amassing 99 points - the highest points total in Spanish league history. They also had to overcome a rejuvenated and very expensively recruited Real Madrid. The competition went down to the last day and Barça only won by three points. Overall Barça dominated the season and only had one serious drop in form. This was immediately after the winter break. They dropped four points in the league, suffering their only defeat - away to Atletico Madrid - and losing out in the Cup to Sevilla, who went on to win that trophy. They reached the semi-finals of the Champions League and were a tad unlucky to lose to Inter Milan, 3-2 on aggregate. However last season Barça were the beneficiaries of good fortune in their semi-final against Chelsea - so you win some and you lose some.
In addition to retaining their League title, Barça also won three more trophies - the Spanish and Uefa Supercups and the big one, the World Club Championship - for the first time in the club’s history. All in all then a great achievement, for as the legendary Johan Cruyff points out, it is easier to reach the top than to stay there, year after year. One has only to compare this season with season 2006-2007. Then Barça had again just won the Champions League (and the Spanish League), but finished the season trophyless. What then was the difference between 2006-2007 and 2009-2010? Two key factors I would suggest. This season Barça has had a slightly bigger and more experienced squad and they have had slightly less injuries. Crucial factors in a long and tiring season.
The three new signings have had mixed fortunes. The most successful was the least expensive - Maxwell who came as cover for Abidal in the left back slot. But with injuries limiting Abidal’s appearances, Maxwell played most of the time, and did so with distinction. Ibrahimović was the most expensive and had the additional challenge of replacing Eto’o, a prolific goalscorer and fans’ favourite. Overall Ibrahimović did well for a first season, scoring 16 league goals. He started the season very well with 11 goals in 13 league matches. After the mid winter break though he was never quite the same. A series of niggling injuries and suspensions meant he was unable to recapture his early season form. Still not a bad return for his first full season. The third newcomer, centre back Chygrinskiy, had a pretty poor season. Ineligible for the Champions League, he found it very difficult to adjust to Barça’s style of play and at times looked slow and cumbersome.
What next?
Pep Guardiola and his team have already begun planning for next season. Which areas of the team most need strengthening? The defence has probably been the most reliable and consistent part of the team this season. Valdés continues his rich vein of form and has at last been rewarded with a place in the Spanish squad for the World Cup. Well done Victor!
The first choice back four of Alves, Piqué, Puyol and Abidal is one of the best in the world. Alas that Abidal missed most of the season through injury. While Maxwell did well as his replacement, he is more of an attacking player who can often be caught out defensively, as happened most noticeably in Milan against Inter in the semi-final of the Champions League. So a key question for Pep and his team is can they rely on Abidal to last a whole season free of injury? If not do they need to get in a top class replacement? On the other flank there is still no cover for Alves. When he is unavailable Puyol moves sideways to fill in. As Puyol started as a right back this is not a bad move, though it does leave the central partnership a bit exposed. For Puyol and Piqué make a tremendous pairing. Going on this season the cover is not too reliable. Marquez seems to be past his best and only played rarely. As did new arrival Chygrinskiy. Half way through the season they did recover Milito who had been out injured for two seasons. However the questions remain, how reliable is Chygrinskiy and is Milito fully recovered and back to his best? As usual with Barça the defence is probably not a priority for the coming season.
What about the midfield, which is usually the great strength of Barça teams. This is the one area where injury did play a significant part in the performance of the team. Iniesta missed about half the season through one kind of injury or another, thus leaving Xavi to shoulder most of the responsibility for creative play. Not that Keita or Touré for that matter do not make useful contributions, but neither has the control or vision of an Iniesta. Which probably explains why Barça are so keen to sign Cesc Fábregas from Arsenal. However Cesc is also prone to injury. If there are serious doubts about Iniesta’s full recovery, signing another (very expensive) injury prone midfielder may not be the best idea. Once again the future may lie with some of Barça’s up and coming youngsters such as Jonathan Dos Santos and Thiago Alcántara. Regarding Touré there are persistent media reports that he is on his way out. Pep Guardiola seems to prefer Busquets as his first choice holding midfielder which does not please Touré. He still gets to play plenty of matches, but will he accept that he is no longer first choice and buckle down to challenging Busquets for the position? If he does go, will Guardiola need to buy in a replacement? Not sure about the youngsters in that position in the B team.
As for the attack this again was not quite as lethal as last season. Though Ibrahimović did not set the heather alight, he did score a respectable 16 league goals. The big difference with last season was the almost complete disappearance of Henry, who rarely played and even more rarely scored. On the other hand Messi just gets better and better. He was the leading goal scorer in the league with 34 goals which equalled the club record held by Ronaldo. Pedro Rodriguez emerged as the leading contender for the third attacking spot, relegating Henry to the bench most of the time. Not only did Pedro score 12 league goals he also scored in all the other competitions Barça played in - a record. Another young player, still only 19 years old, Bojan finished the season strongly, playing instead of Ibrahimović for the latter part of the season, scoring 8 league goals. A comparison between Bojan and Pedro is most interesting. Their scoring record in the league is very similar. Pedro scored 12 goals from 34 matches, which works out at a rate of one goal every 2.83 matches. Bojan’s 8 goals came from 23 matches, half of these as a substitute, yet his goals rate works out at one goal every 2.87 matches. Nothing between them, yet Guardiola clearly prefers Pedro. Mainly I suspect because is a natural wide player who scores useful goals, while Bojan is more of a centre forward, but lacks the height to make the position his own. So when he does play he tends to play wide which is not his natural position. Hard game!
The attack is the one area where Barça have already make their first signing for the new season. David Villa, Spanish international, has joined from Valencia. Villa is a pretty reliable striker both with Valencia and the Spanish national team. His arrival should certainly strengthen Barça’s attacking options. The key question is does his arrival mean the departure of Ibrahimović? The club say no, but the media say yes. Will no doubt depend on how much they get offered for him. Money nearly always talks. However, Villa, though a striker, can play wide and a forward line of Messi, Ibrahimović and Villa looks a very powerful and flexible one. With the likes of Pedro and Bojan in reserve. With the number of games that a team like Barça expect to play, they need all the experienced players they can get. I would expect Ibrahimović to stay for at least the next season. Any other new arrivals? The media are as usual full of stories, imagined or not. With the world cup due to start soon the club will want to get any new signings sorted out sooner rather than later. Watch this space.
Friday, 4 September 2009
Por fin – the new season has begun

Late on Monday evening the final match of the first round of the Spanish League was completed, with FC Barcelona beating Sporting Gijón 3-0. Thus all the European leagues are now underway. Spain as usual is the last to get going, and as usual there is now a hiatus in the league programme as the final series of World Cup qualifying matches take place over the next two weeks. A crazy system!
Anyway the good news for Barça fans and lovers of good football everywhere, is that Barça won in a rather solid more than spectacular performance. The highlight of the match was Zlatan Ibrahimović scoring his first goal for Barça – a diving header to complete the 3-0 scoreline. So far most of the performances have not touched the highs of last season, but at least we are winning. Already two trophies have been won – the Spanish supercup and the European supercup. The Spanish one was won with a 5-1 aggregate victory over Athletic Bilbao, while the European supercup required an extra time winner. Barça dominated all three matches but found it difficult to convert chances into goals, especially against a well disciplined Shakhtar Donetsk defence. Still, two trophies is one more than Barça achieved in the 2006-2007 season the last time they won the Champions League. The Spanish supercup was their sole success in that season. So things are looking a bit better this time round.
As regards the team itself, not much has changed, despite the various comings and goings. Two of the new signings – Keirrison and Henrique - have, as expected gone out immediately on loan. The main additions to the squad have been in defence, with the arrival of Maxwell, from Inter Milan, a left back who should challenge Abidal for this spot. Indeed, Maxwell started the match against Sporting, and looked a good player, but had to be taken off due to injury. The other new defender is Dmitro Chygrynskiy, the Ukrainian international centre back who finally signed from Shakhtar Donetsk, immediately after the European Supercup final. Judging by his performance in that match he looks a very accomplished player and in a short time we could well see him partnering Gerard Piqué at the heart of Barça's defence. With Marquez, Puyol, Maxwell and the two youngsters, Marc Muniesa and Andreu Fontás, the defence is pretty well covered and definitely seems to be stronger than last season.
Up front the main change of course is the arrival of Zlatan Ibrahimović as the new striker in exchange for Samuel Eto'o. It will be very hard for Zlatan to emulate, let alone surpass Eto'o's scoring achievements with Barça. However, he is a very good player and has different strengths to Eto'o, physical presence and heading ability among others. He should do well. The first choice strike partnership of Zlatan, Henry and Messi still looks very, very good. The back up is much the same as last season and most of us will be praying that none of the above succumb to serious injuries as happened during the 2006-2007 season. The main back up will come from the youngsters, Bojan, only just turned 19, and Pedro Rodriguez, who scored the winner against Shakhtar. Both played intermittently last season, so both should be that bit stronger, wiser and more mature. Both played against Sporting, and both played very well, with Bojan scoring the first goal.
It is in midfield where the greatest concern lies. The defensive or holding midfielder role will again be shared by Yaya Touré and Sergi Busquets. So there should be no worries there. It is the attacking, creative roles that give cause for concern. Or, rather the lack of cover that is potentially worrying. The main creative players will again be Xavi and Iniesta, two marvellous players who ended last season playing some wonderful football. Iniesta picked up an injury at the end of last season and has yet to play this season, though he is due to play in Barça's next league match. However, if either or both were to be seriously injured, then there does not appear to be any real cover. Two of last season's back up players, Gudjohnsen and Hleb, have both left. While neither featured much last season, at least both were experienced players. Now the main cover is Keita,who is a very good player, but offers different qualities to either Xavi or Iniesta. The nearest to a Xavi type player seems to be the youngster Jonathan dos Santos, who is only 19 years old. He has yet to play a competitive match for the club, though from brief glimpses he does look a good player. However Guardiola will be praying that he only has to play Jonathan now and again to build up the youngster's confidence and first team experience.
All in all the season has started well. The team is playing well, though below their capacity. From the matches seen so far there is plenty of commitment among the players and the new arrivals will ensure that there is some real competition for first team places. Repeating any of last season's trophies will be very difficult never mind repeating the treble. No team has as yet retained the Champions League, so a real challenge is on there. In Spain a rejuvenated Real Madrid, with a new and highly rated coach and some fabulous new players will push Barça to the limit. However talented players alone do not win trophies, for this you need a team and commitment. If Pellegrini can create a balanced team out of Real's squad, then they will be hard to beat. But then Barça are also hard to beat. If the players show the same commitment as last season then Barça should do as well. Not necessarily in winning trophies, that is always to some extent in the lap of the Gods, but in playing wonderful, exciting football, which is all that we can ask for. Winning trophies is always a bonus. There should be some cracking matches in the Spanish league this season.
Sunday, 2 August 2009
The New Barça takes shape – slowly
The new season for FC Barcelona has finally taken off. With all their stars back in training the full squad plus a couple of youngsters is currently in the United States as part of their pre-season build up. So far there have only been a few changes in personnel. Sylvinho retired and Hleb and Cáceres have left the club for Stuttgart and Juventus respectively. Gudjohnsen may also be leaving if he can find a suitable club. As for newcomers there has been a great deal of media flurry, but little in the way of real transactions.
At present Barça have just three new players, and one of them may not last long. This is Henrique, a Brazilian centre back who was signed last season, but was loaned out to Bundesliga club Bayer Leverkusen. He is now back at Barça, but according to media reports has yet to fully convince Pep Guardiola. The first completely new signing was a surprise – another Brazilian, left back Maxwell, who signed for about €5 million from Inter Milan. Maxwell has previously played with Ajax so has plenty of experience playing in Europe. This looks like a good piece of business for Barça as Maxwell should provide not just emergency cover for Abidal, but should be a real challenger for the left back slot.
The big signing so far has of course been the Swedish striker, Zlatan Ibrahimović, who has come from Inter Milan in a complex deal which involved Eto'o going in the other direction. The total deal is reckoned to be around €65 million, which is a lot of money. Barça will pay about €45 million and the other €20 million is what Eto'o was valued at. Only time will tell how this deal will work out, but Eto'o is a hard act to follow. Zlatan will need to score a lot of goals and important goals at that to even match Eto'o's record let allow beat it. However by all accounts Zlatan is an exceptional player with apparently exquisite touch. Guardiola justified the deal by saying that there was no feeling between him and Eto'o. He used the word in English. Boy, Guardiola sure has balls! You get rid of the club's greatest goal scorer because of a lack of feeling! However, all in all this should work out as a good deal for Barça as the team does need to be shaken up a bit and Zlatan is a very good striker.
Everybody expects that there will be more signings. A wide left player to challenge Henry, a midfielder and a centre back are the three positions that Guardiola would like to strengthen. However that are not that many options available. The great dream was Frank Ribéry, but Bayern Munich want around €80 million. Liverpool's Argentinian holding midfielder, Mascheranno and Arsenal's Cesc Fábregas (an ex Barça youth player) are also on the wanted list, but again the asking price is in the astronomical sphere. Also neither club is really willing to sell anyway. Barça are also apparently interested in Shakhtar Donetsk's Ukrainian international centre back Dmitro Chygrynskiy. The asking fee in this case is “only” €25 million. However Chygrynskiy has now played in a Champions League qualifier so Barça would not want to pay anything like that for someone who would be ineligible for Europe. Their interest in signing another centre back clearly shows a lack of confidence in Henrique. A fall back option is to use one of their own young centre backs, either Marc Muniesa or Andreu Fontás.
Midfield is probably where the team most needs to be strengthened. Hleb has gone and both Keita and Yaya Touré will miss a considerable part of the season when away on international duty at the African Nations Cup. In the case of Touré, Guardiola can always use Rafael Màrquez as the defensive midfielder as he has often played there before. For an attacking midfelder, the club may once again have to rely on home grown talent in the shape of Jonathan Dos Santos. Only 19 years old, Jonathan is already played for Mexico's under 21s.
Up front it is a similar story. With Ribéry discarded there are few options of guaranteed class available. As in previous seasons, Iniesta can always be relied upon to deliver in the wide left position and of course there is the option of using one of their own youngsters, either Pedro Rodríguez or Jeffren Suárez.
The new Barça is taking shape and no doubt there will be a few surprises before the season officially starts. One thing that never ceases to amaze me is the financial position of clubs like Barça. The local Barcelona press are always full of stories about who Barça are about to sign for some astronomical sum and at the same time they frequently state that the club has only a limited transfer budget. No explanation is ever given as to how the club can afford such fantastic outlays. Another bewildering feature of Barça's tranfer policy is their recent ventures into buying a player only to immediately loan him out before he even sets foot inside the Camp Nou. This happened last year with Henrique, signed for €8 million and loaned out to Bayer Leverkusen. If he doesn't make the grade this season what happens – do they try to sell him on? At what price? This year they have done it again, but at a significantly higher price. Another Brazilian, this time a young striker, Keirrison has been signed for €14 million from Plameiras and promptly loaned out to Benfica. I guess the reasoning is that young players from another continent need time to ajust to Europe and European football. If they develop you then have a top class player for not too much outlay. Doesn't seem to have worked yet. Anyway good luck to both Henrique and Keirrison.
So far the pre-season has gone well and if Guardiola can get in a couple of really good signings then the coming season may go pretty well.





