Showing posts with label Euro. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Euro. Show all posts

Thursday, 11 October 2012

Eurozone Prospects

It is getting a bit like Groundhog Day as regards the Euro and its future.  Every month of so, some supposedly very serious commentator, economist or politicians steps up to warn us the there are only two or three months left in which to save the Euro.  And yet two or three years later, the Euro is still there and nobody, not even the Greeks, has left the single currency.  At one level it is all a bit of a laugh.  Unfortunately this is a serious issue and the constant doomsayers are doing us all a major disservice.

Firstly because after a while most people simply cease to believe them and may wrongly, assume that all is well in Euroland.  Secondly, the focus on the survival of the Euro comes at the expense of the underlying economic realties which affect the Eurozone countries.  For the reality is that the main source of the woes affecting European countries is the application of more and more austerity.  Policy makers in nearly all countries seem hell bent on pursuing policies which all the evidence confirms is only making the situation worse.  Government debt is not coming down and most economies are either in recession or flatlining.  That this is happening in the UK, which is not in the Euro, would seem to indicate that it is not the Euro per se, which is the problem, but the "austerity at all costs" policy which is the problem.  Paul Krugman in a recent post outlines the crux of the matter.  Many of our governments seem to want to inflict pain on the rest of us for their own political agendas.

Getting out of this current and long lasting mess will not be easy.  Continuing with the current policy prescription is likely to kill the patient.   It is hard to see how the populations of countries like Spain, Portugal, Greece and even Ireland can continue supporting the consequences of the these policies for much longer.  What they face is a decade or more of deflation with high unemployment and the lost growth that this involves.  Not an enticing prospect.  At some point in the not too distant future something is likely to give.  Either some countries leave the Euro or the current policies will have to change.  Neither will be easy and all governments will try to avoid either happening.  But there has to be a limit to how much suffering people are prepared to endure, especially as there is little prospect of improvement in the medium term.

If the countries of the Eurozone want the Euro to survive there are various options available.  None of them involves rocket science and they have been know about for some time.  American economist Bradford DeLong provides a succinct summary of these options here.  As he points out the most likely outcome is a combination of the following three measures:

Northern Europe tolerates higher inflation – an extra two percentage points for five years would take care of one-third of the total north-south adjustment;
Northern Europe expands social democracy by making its welfare states more lavish;
Southern Europe shrinks its taxes and social services substantially.

Something along these lines is needed pretty soon if the Euro is to survive and the whole of the Eurozone gets a chance to rebalance its economy.  At the moment nobody in either northern or southern Europe is prepared to engage with their electorates about what these measures would mean in practice.  So the majority of Europeans are unaware of what lies ahead.  The sad thing in all this is that to continue as now is more than likely to make things even worse.  We are alas living through very difficult times with a bunch of scared politicians in nominal charge.

Sunday, 3 June 2012

The Euro - One of Two Unthinkable Things Will Happen

It looks like things are going to get even more interesting for the Euro.  The uncertain outcome of the forthcoming general election in Greece has captured most of the attention, but it is events in Spain that are most likely to provide the tipping point  An exit of Greece from the Eurozone while very messy and of uncertain consequences for Greece, would not in itself prove fatal to the Euro.  Damaging yes, possibly very damaging but nevertheless containable.  This, on the economic and political assumption of "all other things being equal".  Which of course is manifestly not the case.  By all accounts Spain is in very serious trouble, with an enormous amount of money needed to clean out its banks.  Where will this money come from?  Even if the money is forthcoming, what effect if any will this have on Spain's disastrous economy?  Massive and rising unemployment and further austerity measures do not add up to much in the way of growth.  On the contrary further contraction is predicted and pretty much inevitable.

Faced with this situation the key question is can the Spanish government continue with its austerity policy?  Could any Spanish government?  While a Greek exit from the Euro would be unfortunate and unwanted - from a Eurozone perspective - a Spanish exit would more or less bring down the whole ship.  Neither Italy nor France could survive in the Euro faced with a massive Spanish devaluation - which is what would happen if Spain leaves the Euro.  The competition would be too severe.  A Spanish exit and devaluation would not be good new for German exporters either, while a collapse of the Euro is likely to be catastrophic for Germany.

Which is why the way forward is likely to involve either of two currently unthinkable outcomes.  Unthinkable that is to the members of the Eurozone.  The two "unthinkables" are 1.  the Euro is allowed to collapse or 2.  Germany accepts lots of debt relief, inflation and monetary transfers to other Eurozone states.  Neither is on the horizon at the moment, but things in the real economy can move at lightning speed.  The phrase about one of two unthinkables happening is from Paul Krugman.  He used it during a very interesting Newsnight programme on BBC2.  The whole programme is well worth watching.  You can access it here via the BBC iplayer.  The programme starts with the situation in Greece and the Krugman section starts at the 20.00 minute mark.  He discusses the options with another US economist, Ken Rogoff and despite their different perspectives, both agree that the only way for the Euro to survive is for Germany to bear a lot of pain.  Rogoff's view is that this will come anyway and it is up to Germany to decide which poison to take.  His prescription is pretty much identical with Krugman's second "unthinkable" - default on loans owed to German banks, higher inflation and financial transfers.  Some combination of all three is probably the optimum solution.  Certainly higher inflation in Germany seems to be the key to any survival of the Euro.  As Krugman points out, it is easier - both practically and politically - to improve Spanish competitiveness by raising the wages of German workers than by lowering the wages of Spanish workers.

The jury is out as to which of the two "unthinkables" will prevail.  The EU leaders will try to postpone any decision for as long as possible, but of course the financial markets may decide to take matters out of their hands and force the issue.  Look out for further signs of capital flight from Spanish banks.  The Newsnight programme also includes a wonderful section - starts at 31.36 minutes - in which Krugman single handed as it were demolishes the so-called arguments of two Neanderthals from the austerity and more austerity camp.  One of them, Andrea Ledson is even a Tory MP - Lord help us!

If the iplayer link above does not work, here is a link via youtoube to the section where Krugman and Rogoff discuss the future of the Euro.  Their discussion starts at 3.40 in.  And here is a link, also via youtoube to the section in which Krugman takes on the austerity monsters.


http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01jhlsz/Newsnight_30_05_2012/

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01jhlsz/Newsnight_30_05_2012/

Friday, 16 December 2011

EU- Fiscal Union Anyone?

The recent flurry of activity at the latest EU summit in Brussels is proving to be a bit of a damp squib.  The proposed new treaty has not exactly set the heather alight and the bond markets remain unconvinced.  One of the minor mysteries about the new treaty is why so many commentators describe it as a move to a Fiscal Union for the Eurozone.  A Fiscal Union may be a good idea, but what is proposed is no such thing.  A bit like French cheeses Fiscal Unions can come in a variety of shapes and disguises.  However there are a few necessary properties of any Fiscal Union.  1.  There has to be some kind of central or common government - let’s call it a Federal government.  2.  This government has the power to set and raise taxes throughout the Union.  3.  The government also has the power to spend the money raised in a way that is deemed to benefit the Union as a whole.  4.  The government will raise more money from the richer parts of the Union and in return, redistribute some of this money in the poorer parts of the Union.
Now the proposals from Brussels do none of the above.  It is a purely inter-governmental arrangement.  It is as Angela Merkel more accurately describes it, a Stability Union.  Unfortunately the only stability the Eurozone has at the moment is the stability of the dead and the dying.  Economically speaking at least!   The new measures will impose even greater austerity on a patient that has suffered from too much austerity already.  Greece and Ireland are already in deep recession and Ireland is supposed to be the Eurozone’s star pupil.
What is missing from all the EU’s endless round of summits is any sense of urgency and in particular any measures to promote growth in the Eurozone.  As with generals, EU leaders are more interested in fighting old wars than in facing up to the realities of the current situation.  To recap, inflation is not a major problem for the foreseeable future and government deficits and national debts did not cause this global crisis.  The current deficits and high levels of debt are primarily symptoms of the crisis and not its cause.  The deficits and debts will only rise, as is happening in the UK, until governments come up with some kind of credible strategy to generate growth in their economies.  Don’t hold your breath.  What we are likely to get is more re-arranging of the deckchairs while the good ship Euro sinks further and further into the mire.  It will probably take some really serious shock - an Irish default?, the collapse of a major French or German bank? to propel our leaders into genuine action.

Friday, 9 December 2011

The Euro - Crisis? What Crisis?

So the big EU summit has come and gone.  The really, really big one we were assured.  Some informed politicians and commentators had even declared in worried tones that we had only 10 days in which to save the Euro, or the EU or both.  Well the 10 days have come and gone and what has happened?  Short answer - not a lot.  Long answer - not a lot.  One is tempted to ask if there really is a Euro crisis after all.
For example take the case of David Cameron, our very own Prime Minister of the UK.  After months lecturing the Eurozone countries on the need for them to get their act together and quickly, what was his big idea at the summit?  Some useful and practical ideas for resolving this crisis which, remember, is so damaging to the future growth prospects for the UK economy?  Hell no, Cameron’s sole contribution to this crisis summit was to insist on cast iron guarantees that the City of London would be forever exempt from any future EU regulation.  Yes, the very same City of London that is home to the banking and financial sector which due to its loose, lax and unregulated practices was the prime cause of the economic and financial woes which threaten all of us.  Clearly David Cameron doesn’t believe there is a Euro crisis.  Otherwise, surely, even he would not risk a collapse of the Euro just to protect rich bankers?
Next up, the rest of the leaders of the EU.  In the face of a threat to the survival of the Euro, what do they do?  Why, let’s negotiate yet another treaty!  One in which everyone solemnly promises that in the future they will behave like good little boys and girls and never, ever borrow lots of money again.  Neverland to the rescue!  And in the meantime?  If this is all it takes to stave off the bond markets then there was never much of a crisis in the first place.
This reading is probably correct in as much as the crisis is not fundamentally about the Euro as a common currency.  It is much more likely to be a banking crisis and a global one at that, in which the US may be more at risk than the EU.  Ann Pettifor has a good summary of this view here.
The summit’s focus on national budgets and deficits is a classic example of our leaders continuing determination to fight the wrong battle.  The most pressing danger facing not just the Eurozone, but the whole of the EU - just look at Germany’s latest export figures - is the real prospect of  deflation and recession.  The weakness of banks is a part of this very real crisis.  And yet the EU has not even begun to work out how to get us out of this mess.  Much easier to draft another treaty.  As usual Paul Krugman has summed up the summit perfectly, if rather pessimistically thus:  “This looks like a disastrous meeting. More austerity, more posing of the crisis, wrongly, as being all about fiscal deficits; no mechanism for ECB funding. Somehow southern Europe is supposed to deflate its way to prosperity, while everyone runs a trade surplus, presumably against that potentially habitable planet we’ve discovered 600 light-years away.
Maybe Draghi’s actions will be very different from his words — but actually, since this is to an important degree about expectations, Europe needs both actions and words.
Oh, and for desertdessert (Oh well — and it’s a floor wax too!) we have Cameron acting as a spoiler to protect the wheeler-dealers, poisoning EU politics.”
How long will we have to wait for an EU summit which tackles the real issues?  The real irony is that it is the failure to come up with positive solutions to avoid deflation and recession that is most likely to bring about the collapse of the Euro - new treaty or not.

Monday, 28 November 2011

Crunch Time for the Euro?

This time it looks like it is serious.  The recent sharp rise in borrowing costs for all Eurozone countries, even Germany, has finally exposed just how bad the situation has become.  Rising borrowing costs and austerity induced recession is pushing the Euro to breaking point.  There is simply no way that Italy and Spain in particular can survive with these high interest rates.  Sooner, rather than later, both of these countries will need to apply for life support from the EU and the IMF or face immediate default.  
Alas for both Spain and Italy there is no more money in the kitty.  Neither the EU nor the IMF has the kind of money needed to support either Spain or Italy, never mind both at the same time.   At this time of crisis, urgent measures are needed, and fast.  Unfortunately the EU is pretty much institutionally incapable of acting urgently.  The solutions not just for Italy and Spain, but for the whole Eurozone, are by now very clear.  They just need our leaders to recognize the inevitable and act accordingly.  This however will be very difficult as both Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy have been so outspoken in opposition to almost all the necessary changes.  They will have to be prepared to eat rather large doses of humble pie very quickly if the Eurozone is to have any chance of survival.  
The outline of the solution comprises three inter-related parts, which need to be put in place pretty much simultaneously.  The first and most urgent of all is to give some relief to Spain and Italy.  This can only be done in the short term by the European Central Bank (ECB).  All the ECB has to do is to act like all other central banks and be the lender of last resort for Eurozone governments in difficulties.  The ECB simply announces that it will buy all Spanish and Italian government bonds at a lowish interest rate, say 3.5%  To do so it will print as many Euros as it takes.  This would immediately end the pressure on all Eurozone countries.  If this was to continue for ever then this policy would lead to higher inflation.  But in the current situation with low underlying inflation and recessions on the horizon, rising inflation is the least of our worries.  This action can be taken very quickly and really only needs the agreement of Angela Merkel, who to date has adamantly refused to countenance such action by the ECB.  Perhaps the threat of the collapse of the Euro will concentrate her mind wonderfully.
The second part of the equation relates to the need for some Eurozone countries, read Italy, Spain, Portugal, Ireland and Greece, to get their respective houses in order, so that they do not face such severe difficulties in the future.  For not unreasonably, Germans and others are a bit reluctant to support countries in trouble unless they can be assured that they will take the necessary measures to get their public finances in order and to make their economies more competitive.  What this crisis has brutally exposed is that though the Eurozone has a common currency it does not have a common state.  It is most unlikely that the Eurozone countries will suddenly agree to set up a joint Federal state à la USA.  However all the talk is of the need to create a Fiscal Union.  This is where things begin to get a bit hazy.  In the first place such a development will take a great deal of time.  It will require a new treaty, which may or may not involve all 27 member states in the EU.  In the case of Ireland any new treaty would probably have to be supported by the electorate in a referendum.  
There is also the tricky matter of just would a Fiscal Union involve?  At the moment it seems to mean that each country in the Eurozone will have to send its budget to Brussels to be scrutinized and approved or rejected by some new supranational Eurozone body.  If rejected the member state would have to revise its budget in line with the changes proposed by this new body.  It the member state refused it would be fined.  Nice in theory, but can anyone see this really working?  If Italy, say, refused to change its budget proposals on the grounds that it would cause too much suffering for poorer Italians, and also refused to pay any fine, would the rest of the Eurozone really force Italy out of the Euro?  In which case it could probably do so now.  
For a Fiscal Union to be credible - to the markets that is - then it almost certainly needs some kind of common Treasury, which would be responsible for most taxation and most government spending in all the Eurozone.  Not a very realistic outcome at the moment, if ever.  Something needs to be done though, if only to make it politically feasible for Angela Merkel to agree to the first proposal - allowing the ECB to buy up government bonds.   She needs to be able to convince her fellow Germans that there will be no backsliding by other Eurozone countries.  The paradox here is that while Germany has been historically quite open to this kind of increased federalism, it is France which has opposed such a loss of sovereignty.  A bit of humble pie for M. Sarkozy to eat.
The final piece of the jigsaw is to get some renewed growth in the Eurozone, in particular in Spain, Italy, Portugal, Greece and Ireland.  Quite how this can be done while the powers that be are still in thraw to the mantra that austerity and ever more austerity is the answer, is not at all clear.  However if Germany does not agree to the above changes to the remit of the ECB, then all the rest becomes academic and very quickly too.  Wolfgang Munchau has a very good piece in the FT in which he reckons the Eurozone has at most 10 days to avoid a rather messy and expensive collapse.

Thursday, 10 November 2011

Is there a Euro Crisis?

One just cannot get away from the Euro and its woes.  Not a day goes by without more talk of gloom and doom.  Greece and Italy face the prospect of severe economic meltdown which could lead to an imminent break up of the Euro.  There has even been talk that Greece might have to leave the EU, not just the Eurozone.  Clearly something pretty bad is going on, but just how bad is it?  In this post I want to try and clarify a couple of questions about this ongoing crisis.  Not sure if I can come up with any answers.
There are two questions I find perplexing and rarely, if ever raised in the media.  The first is why are the undoubted difficulties of Greece and Italy presented as a crisis for the Euro and the Eurozone?  The second and related question is why has a crisis in private banking become a sovereign debt crisis?
As regards the first question, to get an idea of why all this talk of a crisis for the Euro is perplexing it may be useful to compare the situation in the Eurozone with the situation in the USA.  Now the two are not directly comparable, but they do have in common that in each there is a single currency - the Dollar for the USA and the Euro for the Eurozone.  There is also the fact that states in USA as in the Eurozone can get into financial difficulties, quite severe difficulties.  However in the USA there is never any suggestion that financial problems in say, California, will cause anyone to question the survival of the Dollar.  There is also no suggestion that California or any other state would be required to leave the USA.  
Jacques Melitz, professor of economics at Heriot-Watt University in Einburgh has written an article about the lessons for the Euro from the USA.  Talking about the situation in 2010, he writes:  “The crisis brought about dire financing problems for many lower-level government units in the US and some national governments in the Eurozone. According to the spreads on credit default swaps, California and Illinois now have a higher probability of non-performance on public debt than Portugal and Spain. This has been true for months. Consider next the difference in response in the States and Europe. Recently Illinois simply stopped paying $5 billion of bills. In June of last year California issued vouchers for wage payments. In addition, savage cuts in public services have begun and are now threatened in various states in difficulty, not only these two. Nevada has made startling reductions in spending on higher education and welfare. “
So, in the USA when a state engages in irresponsible fiscal conduct it is the creditors and taxpayers who bear the brunt of the consequences.  This is what was supposed to happen in the Eurozone.  At its creation the ECB was explicitly forbidden to act as a lender of last resort and instead it was to be the financial markets that would ensure that member states kept to the true and narrow when it came to national debt.  So why was Greece not just allowed to default way back in 2009?  It could still be in the Eurozone, but it would have had to take very, very harsh measures to bring its public finances into order.  Which it is having to do anyway.  Oh, and there is also the small matter that creditors - the banks and other financial institutions - would have to take a full haircut on their loans.  Not good for the banks.
What about Italy, the current country in the firing line?   There are a couple of points to make here.  One, though Italy’s national debt is pretty high at around 120% of GDP, it is not alone in this.  Japan’s national debt represents 220% of its GDP!  And yet Japan can borrow money at around 1%.  Second point is that Italy is not remotely a basket case.  As the Guardian usefully points out Italy is the eighth largest economy in the world and the fourth largest in Europe. Its gross domestic product (GDP) was over $2tn in 2010. Greece, Europe's other basket case, has a GDP of $305bn – an economy about the same size as Dallas, Fort Worth and Arlington in Texas.  The Italian government clearly needs to implement some serious reforms which will no doubt be painful for lots of Italians.  However the country can afford this.  And it is surely a matter for Italians how they go about sharing the pain.
Daniel Gros, Director of the Centre for European Policy Studies, Brussels, has an interesting article entitled What is holding Italy back.  His conclusion is that it is primarily the lack of good governance which is the biggest hindrance to economic growth.  As he puts it: “This implies that it will be difficult to organise a sustained effort to combat corruption, foster adherence to the rule of law, and improve the efficiency of the administration in general. However, progress on these fronts might in the end be more important for growth than the reforms now being imposed by the EU.”
My second question was How has the crisis become a sovereign debt crisis instead of a banking crisis?  For let us remember that this particular crisis originated way back in 2007 with the exposure of financial malpractice, irresponsibility and corruption by privately owned banks in Iceland, the UK, the USA and Ireland.  Note also that only one of these countries, Ireland is in the Eurozone.  Now one of the key virtues, supposedly, of capitalism and the free market is that there are winners and losers.  Captains of finance get huge, some would say obscene rewards, but this is because they take huge risks.  So, how come when it was time to take a loss, it was the taxpayers who had to step up to the plate?  In most countries the big rise in government debt is primarily due to bailing out private banks.  The ongoing saga of emergency loans to Greece, Ireland and Portugal is to prevent a default and the exposure of banks to meltdown.  Why?
Why are all countries and this includes the so-called virtuous ones like Germany, Austria and Finland, so frightened of bank failures?  After all the failure to tackle the root cause has already led to great suffering in Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain as a direct result of the harsh austerity measures.  This will almost certainly spread to Italy very soon.  However all these austerity measure just add to the downward pressure on the whole EU economies.  Growth for the Eurozone in 2012 has been downgraded to 0.5%.  This will have serious repercussions for Germany and the other so-called virtuous countries.  The loss of exports to the rest of the Eurozone can only lead to higher unemployment in these countries.  And all to prevent a collapse of private banks?  
A collapse of the banking and financial sector would be pretty calamitous, but it would provide the basis for governments to nationalize the banks and ensure that they were brought under proper regulation and control.  Finance is far too important to be left to bankers.  It would also ensure that all countries shared in the pain of rebuilding a sound and sustainable economy.

Monday, 25 July 2011

Another Euro Fix?

The latest round of Eurozone crisis meetings has come and gone.  At least this time they seem to have come up with some small, but useful measures.  Renegotiation of the length of government loans and a reduction in the interest rate charged are all welcome measures.  They will not only benefit Greece, but Ireland and Portugal too.  It also seems that there are to be additional funds to help with the modernisation of Greece’s infrastructures.  All good stuff, but not really addressing any of the main issues.
The first point to emphasize yet again is that this is not really about Greece, or Ireland or Portugal.  The Greek economy only represents about 3% of the GDP of the whole Eurozone.  Germany could probably bail out Greece on its own and still have some change left.  No, the main issue is the solvency of the banking system in the EU, not just the Eurozone.  Just ask RBS!   All these measures are primarily about saving banks, especially French and German banks.  At all costs make sure that Greece does not fully default and thereby expose the whole shaky mess.
The second point is that this is not fundamentally a Euro crisis.  Sure the Euro has plenty of problems and sooner or later the Eurozone countries will have to either agree to break up or to move some way towards fiscal union.  However the fundamental issue of the collapse of the banking and financial system is not primarily a Eurozone matter.  Otherwise why is the UK economy in such a poor and fragile state?  Not to mention the economic woes of the USA.
There is clearly more to this than just saving the Euro and helping Greece.  What needs to be addressed are the twin issues of how to get some growth back in the world economy and how to deal with large trade imbalances.  Neither is primarily a Eurozone issue, though both affect the Eurozone negatively.
Take growth, as without a growing economy the various indebted countries will never to able to repay their loans, even with reduced interest rates.  Yet every country is urged, if not actually forced to implement policies which restrict growth.  Pretty stupid really!  Yet that is the reality of the austerity measures which the IMF and the EU are forcing on all countries.  Here in the UK our nasty Coalition is only too willing to go down this route, without any outside encouragement.  In the UK this is for purely ideological reasons - the Tories as usual want nothing better than to attack the welfare state.  However it is economic madness to cut government spending in a recession or an economic downturn as we have now.  It is also very difficult to do as this article makes clear.  Though based on US experience, its argument is valid for the rest of us.  As we can see only too clearly in the UK, businesses are failing on an apparently weekly basis and there is little or no investment.  Why?  Because there has been a collapse in demand.  And this collapse in demand is primarily due to the cuts in government spending.  Surprise, surprise!  If we are to have any chance of minimising this crisis and returning to growth, then demand has to rise and only the government has the wherewithal to do this.
The other issue that affects us all is trade imbalances.  This is a global phenomenon with some countries - China, Germany and Japan for example - running large and regular trade surpluses.  In the case of Germany this has specific consequences for the Eurozone.  Since all countries cannot run a trade surplus, if Germany is to continue to have a trade surplus, then other countries must of necessity run a trade deficit.  In other words they will continue to import more from Germany than they export to Germany.  Now this is a situation that is pretty much unsustainable in the long run.  In the current situation of economic downturns it becomes critical.  Which is one of the reasons that countries such as Spain, Portugal, Greece etc are in the troubles they are in.  Under the current set-up there is no way that these countries can continue to afford to buy German goods at the rate they have been doing.  The onus here is firmly on Germany as the country that benefits the most from the current situation.  Germany has a rather painful choice to make.  Three options present themselves.  The first is for Germans to start spending more.  This can come via higher wages for German workers and from higher government spending.  This should result in more imports and less exports as the costs of production in Germany rise.  Another option is for Germany to transfer lots of money to the importing countries so that they can continue to buy German goods.  Neither is likely to appeal too much to many Germans.  However the third option is probably even worse.  Countries such as Spain, Portugal, probably Italy as well, leave the Euro and return to the peseta, escudo and the lira.  These currencies would immediately devalue, while the remaining Euro or the Deutschmark (if the Euro broke up completely) would rise in value.  The net result would be that most German goods would be priced out of the market in most other countries, while there would be a boom in exports from these countries.  This would most likely lead to a rise in unemployment in Germany as German companies moved production to southern Europe.  It was precisely to avoid this scenario that Germany agreed to the Euro in the first place.  However unless steps are taken to create some kind of mechanism whereby the profits that Germany makes on its trade surplus can be returned to the importing countries the system will break down.  At great cost to Germany.
So forget about Greece, the real issue is what will Germany do.

Thursday, 25 November 2010

Ireland - Don't Blame the Euro

The Irish crisis is now, temporarily at least, over, but the blame game is already underway.  And for most commentators in the UK and in the USA, the prime suspect is the Euro.  If only Ireland, like clever old UK, had stayed out the Euro, everything would be rosy in the Emerald Isle. 
Now this is a bit rich coming from two countries that have not exactly covered themselves with glory as regards banking collapse.  As I see it four countries have been at the forefront of the banking and financial meltdown.  Iceland, Ireland, the UK and the USA.  Now only one of these countries is in the Eurozone, so what caused the failures in the other countries?  The only thing they all have in common was/is an almost mystical over reliance on a neo-liberal approach to economics and finance, in particular the virtues of de-regulation bordering on no regulation.  Not to mention a too cosy relationship between politicians and the captains of high finance.  
If the Euro by itself were to blame then we would expect similar banking and financial crisis in all or at least most of the Eurozone countries.  Which has not happened.  Sure there are problems for some Eurozone countries, but no one has explained how it is the Euro what has done it.
Now of course our anti Euro and anti EU friends in the UK are not content with blaming the Euro for Ireland’s current woes, they also claim that the Euro is preventing Ireland from getting out of the mess.  Their solution is for Ireland to leave the Euro, devalue and hey presto, once again all will be rosy.  Just as it is here in the UK?   Talk about misjudgements.
This idea that devaluation is the panacea for all countries with economic woes is pretty stupid.  This is not to say that devaluation has not and cannot help some countries.  Devaluation has worked in the past and no doubt will prove useful in the future.  However there are four important caveats about all this.  
In the first place devaluation can only really work if it is just one or two countries which devalue.  If everybody or lots of countries all devalue at the same time, then nobody benefits at all.   Secondly the success of devaluation depends on rising demand somewhere else, preferably from your major trading partners.  The UK has devalued, but ironically its success depends on a strong recovery in the Eurozone.  A weak Euro negates much of the benefits expected from the UK’s devaluation.  While a collapse of the Eurozone and the return of national currencies would probably lead to the collapse of the UK economy as well.  This is why the UK government and even some of the right wing anti Euro press are keen to help Ireland.  
A third point to make is that devaluation does not in itself solve anything.  To the extent that it works, it offers temporary respite for an economy.  But unless the underlying causes of the economic woes are dealt with then the country faces a bleak future of successive devaluations in a vain attempt to become competitive.  My view is that the measures needed to be taken for a country to become more competitive should be taken anyway, with or without devaluation. 
The fourth caveat to devaluation as a policy tool, is that it does bring with it some serious downsides.  While exports should be cheaper, imports will become much more expensive.   Think of the recent rises here in fuel and heating prices.  Not to mention all the other rising prices, many of which are a direct result of the devaluation of the pound.  To the extent that devaluation works, it does so through a reduction in spending power of individuals and households, thus leading to a reduction in living standards for most of the population.
This is what is happening in the UK just now.  Wage freezes, tax rises and rising prices.  Not that much different to what is going on in Ireland just now.  Though there the fall in spending power is more obvious as it comes through cuts in wages.  The cuts in Ireland are more severe than in the UK, but this is all due to the continuing rise in the national debt.  Which in turn is pretty much all due to the need to bail out the banks.  
Which of course should lead to the most interesting question of all - why should the Irish taxpayer bail out private banks?
Let us not pretend that this is just to protect Irish banks.  As I have mentioned before, other countries have significant exposure to Ireland.  The UK alone has around €150 million at risk, while Germany has nearly €140 millions.  Other countries have lesser, but still significant amounts at risk if the Irish economy were to collapse.  Hence the need to keep Ireland afloat.  Offer the Irish government a massive loan and persuade/bully the Irish taxpayer into cutting his/her living standards in order to pay it back.  
This is pretty much theft and blackmail of the worst kind.  And all to protect the UK and European banks and financial companies from losses.  Unfortunately, at least for the banks, but perhaps fortunately for the Irish taxpayer, this little scheme will not work.   With all the austerity measures now in place there is simply no way the Irish economy can generate the taxes needed to enable the government to repay these loans.  At some point the Irish will say enough is enough and refuse to go on with this charade.
The real problem facing Ireland is not a liquidity crisis but a solvency crisis.  The country is essentially bankrupt.  And all because of the colossal mismanagement and reckless incompetence of its private banks.  Private debts which an even more incompetent government has now turned into national debts.  For without the need to bail out the banks the Irish economy would already be well on the way to recovery.  This year the economy had begun to grow again and exports had started to pick up.  But the further austerity measures just announced will only make matters worse.
What Ireland needs to do is get rid of the banks’ debt.  In a private sector market economy the way to do this is through bankruptcy.  Some, at least, of the Irish banks should have been allowed or if necessary forced into bankruptcy.  This would have course placed some of the losses back onto the shareholders of UK and other European banks.  But, hey, this is what market risk is supposed to be about.  Why should the taxpayer pay all the bills while the shareholders get all the profits?
A quick look at Iceland, one of the other small countries to be badly affected by the financial crisis, shows the benefits of this approach.  Both countries have recorded similar performances but with less unemployment in Iceland.  And one of the key reasons for this?  According to  the IMF’s latest report on Iceland - “private sector bankruptcies have led to a marked decline in external debt.”  The report also goes on to praise “the focus on preserving Iceland’s valued Nordic social welfare model.”
There would seem to be some interesting lessons for the Irish to ponder over Iceland’s recent experiences.  Most importantly, if Ireland wants to avoid the risk of the whole country having to declare itself bankrupt, then it needs to revoke its blanket guarantee to cover all the liabilities of its banks and allow some of them to fail.  Better a private bankruptcy than the impoverishment of the whole country.