So that's it then. The game is up, no need to bother with the referendum. Might as well concede defeat now. That seems to be the message from Unionists after the recent pronouncements of Jose Manuel Barroso, the President of the European Commission. In an interview with BBC radio he stated in response to a question about Scottish independence that, "For European Union purposes, from a legal point of view, it is certainly a new state. If a country becomes independent it is a new state and has to negotiate with the EU." The full transcript can be found here. In passing it is interesting to note that he uses the verb negotiate, while at other times he uses the verb apply. Seems to be a bit of confusion in Sr Barroso's mind.
As regards the substance of all this, it is not at all clear why anyone is making a fuss about his remarks. After independence Scotland will become a new state! Wow, I never knew that. And this new state will have to negotiate with the EU. Wow! So many things I never knew before. Let us all bless the great and supremely knowledgeable Sr Barroso for bringing us all this enlightenment. Like all Unionist in this debate, Sr Barroso leaves out the key and salient fact that this negotiation will take place while Scotland is still part of the EU - ie from within the EU. For after a Yes vote and until such time as the details of independence have been settled and signed, Scotland will remain part of the UK and thus part of the EU.
Further to this there is the crucial matter of how the UK government, about to become rUK, will react. It is pretty much inconceivable that the rUK would not want to develop and maintain close and cordial relations with an independent Scotland, just as it does with the Republic of Ireland. Which let us not forgot was also once upon a time a part of the UK. So, following a Yes vote, it will be the rUK, led by David Cameron who will be contacting the Commission to inform them that the UK is changing and that Scotland will in, let us say, two years time become independent. He will also have the pleasure of informing the Commission that this new state wants to maintain its membership of the EU and could the Commission kindly make the necessary arrangements. What is the Commission going to say? Sorry old bloke, we are very busy, so come back in five years time? The reality is that it will be in the interest of the rUK for Scotland to become a full member of the EU and it will also be in the interests of the rUK for the negotiations to run smoothly. Any demands on Scotland that would impact on rUK, such as compulsory membership of the Schengen agreement would be strenuously resisted by rUK. Equally all talk about Scotland being forced to join the Euro is misplaced and betrays an ignorance of the EU treaties and procedures. For details see this article.
There is also the rather important matter of EU citizenship to consider in relation to Scotland's continuing membership of the EU. While in theory EU citizenship is additional to member state citizenship, it may be impossible to disentangle this in practice. This is particularly pertinent in the case of the UK, which continues to recognise dual citizenship. The relationship of the Republic of Ireland with the UK is a factor in this. People in Northern Ireland for example can opt for either UK or Irish citizenship or both. In the likely event that an independent Scotland allows for dual citizenship, we would have the situation in which a large number of people living in an independent Scotland continued to have a UK passport and thus UK and EU citizenship. There is no precedent for the UK to take citizenship away from current passport holders. So, if the EU were to deny an independent Scotland full membership of the EU, they would have to work out how to deal with the millions of Scots who retained their UK passport, either instead of or in addition to a Scottish one. Even an arch Unionist like Eric Joyce, Labour MP regards all this talk about exclusion from the EU as nonsense. His views can be read here. For a more detailed look at the implications of dual citizenship see this submission from Professor Jo Shaw, Salvesen Chair of European Institutions, University of Edinburgh.
As a concluding point it is worth noting that when asked about the position of the rUK and if it would have to renegotiate its terms, his reply was, "No, no in principle no." Interesting choice of words, for of course, no in principle usually means yes in practice. For the rUK will in fact have plenty to negotiate about - the size of its rebate, the size of its contribution to the EU budget, not forgetting the size of its representation within the Parliament and the Council of Ministers.
All in all it is clear that the rUK will do everything possible to ensure a smooth transition for Scotland to full membership of the EU - in its own interests.
Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts
Tuesday, 11 December 2012
Friday, 23 November 2012
EU Budget - Round 1
The latest stushie over the budget for the EU is about par for the course. Remember this is the EU, all 27 member states trying to agree on a budget for the next seven years. Last time around it took three European Council meetings to reach agreement. So, failing to reach a consensus at the first attempt is no big deal. The process of agreeing a budget though does tell us a lot about the strengths and weaknesses of the EU as currently constituted.
Some background first, which may clear some things up a bit. This is not really a dispute about the budget, which is usually a one year plan. Rather this debate is about the MFF or the Multiannual Financial Framework. The Danish government usefully explained what this is, earlier in the year, when Denmark held the rotating Presidency of the Council. "Since the end of the 1980’s the EU’s annual budgets have been laid down within the framework of multiannual budget agreements – the so-called multiannual financial frames, also abbreviated to MFF (Multiannual Financial Framework).
The frames constitute the expenditure ceilings for the main areas of expenditure determined by the Council, the European Parliament and the Commission for a number of years. The current budget ceilings have been settled for the period 2007-2013, and as the next multiannual financial frames are to be negotiated for 2014-2020, talks are already under way.
Some background first, which may clear some things up a bit. This is not really a dispute about the budget, which is usually a one year plan. Rather this debate is about the MFF or the Multiannual Financial Framework. The Danish government usefully explained what this is, earlier in the year, when Denmark held the rotating Presidency of the Council. "Since the end of the 1980’s the EU’s annual budgets have been laid down within the framework of multiannual budget agreements – the so-called multiannual financial frames, also abbreviated to MFF (Multiannual Financial Framework).
The frames constitute the expenditure ceilings for the main areas of expenditure determined by the Council, the European Parliament and the Commission for a number of years. The current budget ceilings have been settled for the period 2007-2013, and as the next multiannual financial frames are to be negotiated for 2014-2020, talks are already under way.
The financial framework requires unanimity in the Council of Ministers when it has been approved by a majority in the Parliament."
If you are really keen or sad, and would like to know even more about the MFF you can consult this helpful document provided by the Council. As can be seen from the Danish outline, the MFF negotiatons involve a lot of institutions and the Danish paper omits one of them, perhaps the most important one of all. For in addition to the Council; the European Parliament and the Commission, the MFF proposals have first of all to be agreed unanimously by the European Council. Confused? Welcome to the byzantine world of the EU.
The two Councils referred to above both represent the governments of the member states in the EU decision making process. The fact that governments have two bites at the cherry, as it were, says a lot about where the real power lies within the EU. The Council (full name, the Council of the European Union) is where the day to day decisions about EU policies are taken. If the issue is to do with finance, then the Finance Ministers of each member state come along and decide what to do, usually by qualified majority voting. If the issue is agriculture for example, then the Agriculture Ministers would make up the Council. The Council has a rotating Presidency, lasting six months and the current Presidency is Cyprus. The website for the Cyprus Presidency is here. However for the really big issues, such as the overall budget ceiling or the MFF, it is the heads of state or government who meet and decide. When these august people meet they call themselves the European Council. You can get their website here. And it was a meeting of this Council which failed to reach agreement earlier today.
The two other European institutions, the European Parliament and the Commission are supposed to represent the common interest of all Europeans and not the interests of the member states. However as can be seen from the media coverage of the budget, all the power lies with the governments of the member states.
This imbalance of power within the EU can be seen as either a strength or weakness. As a strength it ensures that the EU in its collective actions and policies is subject to the member states. There are three weakness with this imbalance though. Firstly the need for unanimity or even a qualified majority means that decision making can be a very slow and laborious process. Often so slow that action when it comes can be too little and/or too late to make much real difference. The power given to the governments of the member states allows national politicians to indulge in lots of excessive posturing. The final weakness is that by giving the decisive powers to the governments of the member states there has been no development of a popular EU wide politics. Everything is approached and seen and reported in the media through a national lens.
This is unlikely to change any time soon. It is hard to see member states giving up any of the powers they currently have. So we can expect a lot more posturing and horse trading, all in the name of the well being of the EU as a whole.
Monday, 14 May 2012
More Electoral Shocks for the Austerians
After the recent triumph of François Hollande in France and the success of the anti austerity parties in Greece comes another major reverse for those in favour of austerity. In Angela Merkel's homeland her party, CDU has just suffered a calamitous defeat in North Rhine Westphalia, the most populous of the German Länder. Her party's vote declined by over 8%, while the main opposition party, the SPD saw their vote share rise. The SPD will now continue to run the state in coalition with the Greens, but this time with an overall majority. The photo above shows the victorious Hannelore Kraft the leader of the SPD in North Rhine Westphalia.
This result while a clear set back for Angela Merkel, does not in itself weaken her in the Federal Parliament in Berlin, where she continues to enjoy a clear majority with the support of the FDP. However it is a further indication of the strength of those opposed to further austerity. It is worth pointing out that this was not a simple anti incumbent vote as the SPD and the Greens were the governing coalition in Düsseldorf. Most of all it is further confirmation that the tide is turning in favour of concrete measures across Europe to promote growth. None of the main parties anywhere is arguing against the need to bring down national debt or to reduce excessive government deficits. But more and more political parties and groups are vociferously arguing for a longer timetable for debt and deficit reduction and the absolute need to get all European economies growing again. The situation in Spain continues to worsen with one major bank already effectively nationalised. Will Greece have a national unity government by the end of today or will there have to be fresh elections next month? Uncertainty and worry everywhere, with more and more families suffering real reductions in their living standards. Austerity is manifestly not working. This week's meeting between François Hollande and Angela Merkel may give us the first indications of whether and how far Merkel is prepared to move. Alas, we live in interesting times.
This result while a clear set back for Angela Merkel, does not in itself weaken her in the Federal Parliament in Berlin, where she continues to enjoy a clear majority with the support of the FDP. However it is a further indication of the strength of those opposed to further austerity. It is worth pointing out that this was not a simple anti incumbent vote as the SPD and the Greens were the governing coalition in Düsseldorf. Most of all it is further confirmation that the tide is turning in favour of concrete measures across Europe to promote growth. None of the main parties anywhere is arguing against the need to bring down national debt or to reduce excessive government deficits. But more and more political parties and groups are vociferously arguing for a longer timetable for debt and deficit reduction and the absolute need to get all European economies growing again. The situation in Spain continues to worsen with one major bank already effectively nationalised. Will Greece have a national unity government by the end of today or will there have to be fresh elections next month? Uncertainty and worry everywhere, with more and more families suffering real reductions in their living standards. Austerity is manifestly not working. This week's meeting between François Hollande and Angela Merkel may give us the first indications of whether and how far Merkel is prepared to move. Alas, we live in interesting times.
Tuesday, 8 May 2012
The Beginning of the End for Austerity?
The election results in France and Greece give rise to hope that at long last the tide may be about to turn in the Eurozone. There is most certainly a pressing need for the Eurozone countries to get out of the neo-liberal austerity driven mess they are in. Paul Krugman and Martin Wolf have both recently published interesting articles demonstrating that austerity does not and is not working. Krugman’s article is here and Wolf’s article is here. Martin Wolf’s research shows conclusively that: “In all, there is no evidence that large fiscal contractions bring benefits to confidence and growth that offset the direct effects of the contractions. They bring exactly what one would expect: small contractions bring recessions and big contractions bring depressions.” Would the Messrs Cameron, Clegg and Osborne take note.
The great worry, loudly and constantly repeated is that the markets and in particular the bond markets will punish countries that do not stick to austerity measures. Yet there is no evidence that the bond markets reward austerity. Ireland has ruthlessly pursued a massive fiscal contraction over the past few years with no benefits in terms of access to the bond markets. Spain is now in a similar situation. The new very right wing government has embarked on a similarly ruthless policy of fiscal contraction and its reward? The bond markets have reduced Spain’s credit rating even further.
It is not hard to see why, with all these austerity measures where is the growth in the Spanish economy going to come from? And without growth how can Spain repay its existing loans? It is a downward spiral which benefits no-one. Even the markets are telling everyone that austerity is not the answer. Or at least that austerity on its own is certainly not the answer.
This is where the election of François Hollande as the new French President could be crucial. Along with the Greek voters comprehensively rejecting the pro austerity parties in their general election. These two countries are not alone. In the Netherlands the coalition government collapsed after a right wing party rejected further austerity measures. A general election will now be held later this year. And the two Mario’s have added their voices to the call for measures to stimulate growth. I refer to Mario Monti the technocrat Prime Minister of Italy and Mario Draghi the President of the ECB. Even the European Commission is beginning to stir as Olli Rehn the Economics Commissioner has added his voice to the demands for a rethink on austerity. Rehn is calling for a European Investment Pact to boost growth in the Eurozone.
What is interesting about these new voices calling for a programme for growth is that that they are coming from all sides of the political spectrum. It is not just the socialist Hollande who is demanding a rethink, but centrist and even right wing politicians. Even the ultra right wing Mariano Rajoy in Spain must be desperate for some change in policy given the disastrous state of the Spanish economy and the way it is being punished by the markets.
We must not allow ourselves to get carried away by all this. As the title of this post suggests we may be at the beginning of a move away from neo-liberal rigidity, but there is a long way to go. As expected Angela Merkel has already announced that there is to be no back tracking on the fiscal pact. However the forces aligning up against her and her ilk are getting stronger and stronger and as I mentioned earlier, it cannot be dismissed as coming from the usual suspects on the left. No one expects the Eurozone to suddenly change gear completely. Austerity measures will remain, but their force may be reduced somewhat and the timescale may be revised. The most we can hope for in the immediate future is that some concrete measures are put in place to stimulate real growth throughout the Eurozone. The battle is only beginning but at long last credible voices are emerging to challenge the dead end doctrine of neo-liberalism.
Friday, 16 December 2011
EU- Fiscal Union Anyone?
The recent flurry of activity at the latest EU summit in Brussels is proving to be a bit of a damp squib. The proposed new treaty has not exactly set the heather alight and the bond markets remain unconvinced. One of the minor mysteries about the new treaty is why so many commentators describe it as a move to a Fiscal Union for the Eurozone. A Fiscal Union may be a good idea, but what is proposed is no such thing. A bit like French cheeses Fiscal Unions can come in a variety of shapes and disguises. However there are a few necessary properties of any Fiscal Union. 1. There has to be some kind of central or common government - let’s call it a Federal government. 2. This government has the power to set and raise taxes throughout the Union. 3. The government also has the power to spend the money raised in a way that is deemed to benefit the Union as a whole. 4. The government will raise more money from the richer parts of the Union and in return, redistribute some of this money in the poorer parts of the Union.
Now the proposals from Brussels do none of the above. It is a purely inter-governmental arrangement. It is as Angela Merkel more accurately describes it, a Stability Union. Unfortunately the only stability the Eurozone has at the moment is the stability of the dead and the dying. Economically speaking at least! The new measures will impose even greater austerity on a patient that has suffered from too much austerity already. Greece and Ireland are already in deep recession and Ireland is supposed to be the Eurozone’s star pupil.
What is missing from all the EU’s endless round of summits is any sense of urgency and in particular any measures to promote growth in the Eurozone. As with generals, EU leaders are more interested in fighting old wars than in facing up to the realities of the current situation. To recap, inflation is not a major problem for the foreseeable future and government deficits and national debts did not cause this global crisis. The current deficits and high levels of debt are primarily symptoms of the crisis and not its cause. The deficits and debts will only rise, as is happening in the UK, until governments come up with some kind of credible strategy to generate growth in their economies. Don’t hold your breath. What we are likely to get is more re-arranging of the deckchairs while the good ship Euro sinks further and further into the mire. It will probably take some really serious shock - an Irish default?, the collapse of a major French or German bank? to propel our leaders into genuine action.
Friday, 9 December 2011
The Euro - Crisis? What Crisis?
So the big EU summit has come and gone. The really, really big one we were assured. Some informed politicians and commentators had even declared in worried tones that we had only 10 days in which to save the Euro, or the EU or both. Well the 10 days have come and gone and what has happened? Short answer - not a lot. Long answer - not a lot. One is tempted to ask if there really is a Euro crisis after all.
For example take the case of David Cameron, our very own Prime Minister of the UK. After months lecturing the Eurozone countries on the need for them to get their act together and quickly, what was his big idea at the summit? Some useful and practical ideas for resolving this crisis which, remember, is so damaging to the future growth prospects for the UK economy? Hell no, Cameron’s sole contribution to this crisis summit was to insist on cast iron guarantees that the City of London would be forever exempt from any future EU regulation. Yes, the very same City of London that is home to the banking and financial sector which due to its loose, lax and unregulated practices was the prime cause of the economic and financial woes which threaten all of us. Clearly David Cameron doesn’t believe there is a Euro crisis. Otherwise, surely, even he would not risk a collapse of the Euro just to protect rich bankers?
Next up, the rest of the leaders of the EU. In the face of a threat to the survival of the Euro, what do they do? Why, let’s negotiate yet another treaty! One in which everyone solemnly promises that in the future they will behave like good little boys and girls and never, ever borrow lots of money again. Neverland to the rescue! And in the meantime? If this is all it takes to stave off the bond markets then there was never much of a crisis in the first place.
This reading is probably correct in as much as the crisis is not fundamentally about the Euro as a common currency. It is much more likely to be a banking crisis and a global one at that, in which the US may be more at risk than the EU. Ann Pettifor has a good summary of this view here.
The summit’s focus on national budgets and deficits is a classic example of our leaders continuing determination to fight the wrong battle. The most pressing danger facing not just the Eurozone, but the whole of the EU - just look at Germany’s latest export figures - is the real prospect of deflation and recession. The weakness of banks is a part of this very real crisis. And yet the EU has not even begun to work out how to get us out of this mess. Much easier to draft another treaty. As usual Paul Krugman has summed up the summit perfectly, if rather pessimistically thus: “This looks like a disastrous meeting. More austerity, more posing of the crisis, wrongly, as being all about fiscal deficits; no mechanism for ECB funding. Somehow southern Europe is supposed to deflate its way to prosperity, while everyone runs a trade surplus, presumably against that potentially habitable planet we’ve discovered 600 light-years away.
Maybe Draghi’s actions will be very different from his words — but actually, since this is to an important degree about expectations, Europe needs both actions and words.
Oh, and for desertdessert (Oh well — and it’s a floor wax too!) we have Cameron acting as a spoiler to protect the wheeler-dealers, poisoning EU politics.”
How long will we have to wait for an EU summit which tackles the real issues? The real irony is that it is the failure to come up with positive solutions to avoid deflation and recession that is most likely to bring about the collapse of the Euro - new treaty or not.
Monday, 28 November 2011
Crunch Time for the Euro?
This time it looks like it is serious. The recent sharp rise in borrowing costs for all Eurozone countries, even Germany, has finally exposed just how bad the situation has become. Rising borrowing costs and austerity induced recession is pushing the Euro to breaking point. There is simply no way that Italy and Spain in particular can survive with these high interest rates. Sooner, rather than later, both of these countries will need to apply for life support from the EU and the IMF or face immediate default.
Alas for both Spain and Italy there is no more money in the kitty. Neither the EU nor the IMF has the kind of money needed to support either Spain or Italy, never mind both at the same time. At this time of crisis, urgent measures are needed, and fast. Unfortunately the EU is pretty much institutionally incapable of acting urgently. The solutions not just for Italy and Spain, but for the whole Eurozone, are by now very clear. They just need our leaders to recognize the inevitable and act accordingly. This however will be very difficult as both Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy have been so outspoken in opposition to almost all the necessary changes. They will have to be prepared to eat rather large doses of humble pie very quickly if the Eurozone is to have any chance of survival.
The outline of the solution comprises three inter-related parts, which need to be put in place pretty much simultaneously. The first and most urgent of all is to give some relief to Spain and Italy. This can only be done in the short term by the European Central Bank (ECB). All the ECB has to do is to act like all other central banks and be the lender of last resort for Eurozone governments in difficulties. The ECB simply announces that it will buy all Spanish and Italian government bonds at a lowish interest rate, say 3.5% To do so it will print as many Euros as it takes. This would immediately end the pressure on all Eurozone countries. If this was to continue for ever then this policy would lead to higher inflation. But in the current situation with low underlying inflation and recessions on the horizon, rising inflation is the least of our worries. This action can be taken very quickly and really only needs the agreement of Angela Merkel, who to date has adamantly refused to countenance such action by the ECB. Perhaps the threat of the collapse of the Euro will concentrate her mind wonderfully.
The second part of the equation relates to the need for some Eurozone countries, read Italy, Spain, Portugal, Ireland and Greece, to get their respective houses in order, so that they do not face such severe difficulties in the future. For not unreasonably, Germans and others are a bit reluctant to support countries in trouble unless they can be assured that they will take the necessary measures to get their public finances in order and to make their economies more competitive. What this crisis has brutally exposed is that though the Eurozone has a common currency it does not have a common state. It is most unlikely that the Eurozone countries will suddenly agree to set up a joint Federal state à la USA. However all the talk is of the need to create a Fiscal Union. This is where things begin to get a bit hazy. In the first place such a development will take a great deal of time. It will require a new treaty, which may or may not involve all 27 member states in the EU. In the case of Ireland any new treaty would probably have to be supported by the electorate in a referendum.
There is also the tricky matter of just would a Fiscal Union involve? At the moment it seems to mean that each country in the Eurozone will have to send its budget to Brussels to be scrutinized and approved or rejected by some new supranational Eurozone body. If rejected the member state would have to revise its budget in line with the changes proposed by this new body. It the member state refused it would be fined. Nice in theory, but can anyone see this really working? If Italy, say, refused to change its budget proposals on the grounds that it would cause too much suffering for poorer Italians, and also refused to pay any fine, would the rest of the Eurozone really force Italy out of the Euro? In which case it could probably do so now.
For a Fiscal Union to be credible - to the markets that is - then it almost certainly needs some kind of common Treasury, which would be responsible for most taxation and most government spending in all the Eurozone. Not a very realistic outcome at the moment, if ever. Something needs to be done though, if only to make it politically feasible for Angela Merkel to agree to the first proposal - allowing the ECB to buy up government bonds. She needs to be able to convince her fellow Germans that there will be no backsliding by other Eurozone countries. The paradox here is that while Germany has been historically quite open to this kind of increased federalism, it is France which has opposed such a loss of sovereignty. A bit of humble pie for M. Sarkozy to eat.
The final piece of the jigsaw is to get some renewed growth in the Eurozone, in particular in Spain, Italy, Portugal, Greece and Ireland. Quite how this can be done while the powers that be are still in thraw to the mantra that austerity and ever more austerity is the answer, is not at all clear. However if Germany does not agree to the above changes to the remit of the ECB, then all the rest becomes academic and very quickly too. Wolfgang Munchau has a very good piece in the FT in which he reckons the Eurozone has at most 10 days to avoid a rather messy and expensive collapse.
Monday, 21 November 2011
Does the Left have a Future?
The recent election in Spain has only served to confirm a trend that has been apparent for a number of years now. The collapse in votes for the the Socialist Workers Party (PSOE) and the left in general mirrors that in other countries. Something similar happened in the UK at last year’s general election. According to one of the Spanish newspapers 24 of the 27 countries in the EU now have right of centre governments. This might appear to be a ringing endorsement of the right, but this is not necessarily so.
In most cases it is more a case of throwing out the incumbents and giving the other lot a chance. Without it must also be said any great enthusiasm on the part of the electorate. Certainly in Spain the victorious People’s Party (PP) offered no new thinking about how to combat the crisis. Indeed by all accounts they offered no ideas at all. The Socialists were rightly blamed for failing to do anything about the crisis and were kicked out. But few Spaniards are much enamoured with the PP.
With all these right wing governments in power you would think that there should be some kind of consensus about how to deal with the crisis. But this is manifestly not the case. There is little agreement among the various governments and even the much vaunted Franco-German duopoly seems to be further apart than ever on ways forward.
It must also be pointed out that in the elections to come over the next two years or so, in France, Italy and Germany there is every possibility that the left in some form will be returned to power. However if this does happen it will be more a result of the unpopularity of the incumbents than anything positive the left has to offer.
For this is the key question for all those on the left of the political spectrum. What does the Left have to offer? Does the Left have any kind of coherent story to tell about what caused the crisis and how to get out of it? It appears not. Certainly in the UK, Labour is still pretty much stuck in the by now widely discredited neo-liberal strait-jacket. All it offers is a bit less in the size and pace of the cuts. It remains to be seen whether François Hollande and his team can come up with something more convincing.
A further question is what is the Left now anyway? Apart from the traditional big parties, who all contributed in one way or another to the crisis, who else is around on the Left? There are plenty of parties out there, but few ever manage to win representation in Parliament. In Spain the United Left (IU), a reincarnation of the once powerful Communist Party manage to win just 7% of the votes. While other left parties, particularly in Catalunya, Galicia and the Basque country also won votes, the overall total cannot have much more than 10% if that.
This it has to be said is pretty pathetic. Why has the mainstream Left been so willing to side up to bankers and big business in general instead of standing up for working people? And why have the small, more radical Left parties completely failed to win the trust of more than a handful of voters? It cannot all be down to the media. Something very bad has happened to the Left. The current situation should be a godsend to parties on the Left. Falling incomes in real terms for most workers, rising unemployment and severe cuts to public services and welfare benefits should be ideal territory for the Left to work out a coherent programme to get us out of this mess. The trouble with economic crisis is that too often in the past they have been used to further the nasty authoritarian right. If the Left fails to rise to this challenge this could get ever nastier.
Just why the Left has failed to come up with a coherent story is most perplexing. The evidence of what has happened over the last five decades is overwhelming and out there in the public domain. The following example all refer to the USA, but the big picture is unlikely to be that different in the EU. To get an idea of just how rich the super, super rich really are, Singapore based Wealth-X has usefully identified just who they are and how much wealth they own. For the world as a whole, some 186,000 individuals hold $25 trillion in combined wealth. In the USA, around 59,000 individuals hold a combined net worth of $7.6 trillion. To which the only response is WOW! Surely the Left can come up with some modest proposals to tax some of this wealth? One such modest proposal can be found here.
Not only have the super rich become more and more wealthy, they have done so at the expense of the rest of us. Hence the contrast between the 1% at the top and the 99% of us somewhere around the bottom. An excellent article in Business Insider charts just how this inequality gap has developed over the previous decades. The writer sums it all up rather nicely: “The problem in a nutshell is this: Inequality in this country has hit a level that has been seen only once in the nation's history, and unemployment has reached a level that has been seen only once since the Great Depression. And, at the same time, corporate profits are at a record high. In other words, in the never-ending tug-of-war between "labor" and "capital," there has rarely—if ever—been a time when "capital" was so clearly winning.”
If that is not a rallying cry for a Left alternative then the game is trully over. There is a fairly simple story out there, but we need, desperately need a new generation of leaders to articulate this in a way that will win the trust and votes of the majority of the population. Ed Milliband anyone?
Monday, 14 November 2011
Italy and Greece - Democracy in Danger?
The saying that a week is a long time in politics has never been better illustrated than by the recent momentous events in Greece and Italy. In both countries we now have new governments in record time. Or at least new Prime Ministers. It is too early to comment on whether the new teams will make any difference to the travails of their respective countries. We will need to wait bit longer than the proverbial one week for this.
However even before the new Prime Ministers were nominated, there has been a chorus of criticism from both the left and the right, condemning the changes as undemocratic. The argument is that the new Prime Ministers are unelected and that Greece and Italy have been more or less told what to do by the EU. Germany and France are singled out for particular blame in this respect. Indeed some of the comments from the right have used this as an opportunity to express their hatred of almost anything to do with Germany. It seems that the Fourth Reich is upon us.
I find all this most unconvincing. In the first place it is not the EU which has caused the political crisis in Greece and Italy. The crisis in Greece started over a year ago when the global financial markets lost trust in Greek government bonds. In Italy the situation only reached crisis proportions recently. But again it was the global financial markets which made the judgement that Italy’s debt was unsustainable. The changes in government in both countries is all about trying to regain trust from these all powerful markets. It is not the EU that has forced the changes.
The second point to make is that in both countries the formation of the new governments has followed the traditional constitutional norms. The key point here is that both Papandreou in Greece and Berlusconi in Italy had lost their majority in Parliament. Thus they had no alternative but to offer their resignations to their President. In normal circumstances this would probably lead to elections. But these are hardly normal circumstances. So it is perfectly proper for the President to open discussions with the leaders of the political parties in Parliament to see if there is the prospect of forming a new government with majority support.
This is the third point I would like to make. In both countries the new government will only survive if it wins support in Parliament. There is no subverting the constitution. It is also worth pointing out that this kind of thing is not that rare. Especially in Italy where in the 60‘s and 70‘s governments often changed two or three times within the lifetime of a Parliamentary term.
I am most bemused by the claim that the new Prime Ministers are unelected. This bemusement is partly due to the confusion about what the exact complaint is. Since neither of the new Prime Ministers is an elected MP then one can say that at one level they are unelected. However in the context of becoming Prime Minister this seems a very narrow objection. Firstly because getting elected as a MP is only ever a matter for a very small part of the whole electorate. It may be as small as a single constituency with only 80 000 electors. In a PR system the electorate will be larger, but still only a small part of the whole country. And in most PR systems it is your placement on the list that most determines whether you get elected or not. Whatever the case it is hard to put forward much of a positive case that election by a tiny percentage of the whole national electorate is somehow a necessary precondition for becoming a Prime Minister.
I suspect that the main criticism is that there has not been a general election. However this betrays a misunderstanding of how a Parliamentary system works. Whatever the electoral system in use, an elector can only vote for either one candidate or one party. In no way whatsoever can the electorate as a whole vote directly for who will be Prime Minister. Only MPs can vote for who will be Prime Minister.
This is most clearly seen in the UK. At the last election no party won a majority of seats and none came remotely close to winning an overall majority of the votes. So who precisely voted for David Cameron as Prime Minister? Certainly not the electorate. The only people who could vote for David Cameron were those who were registered in his constituency. Not much of a popular mandate there. Yet no-one, or virtually no-one questions his legitimacy or his democratic credentials. In the previous Parliament we also had the case where Gordon Brown replaced Tony Blair as Prime Minister without a general election. As the Labour party had a substantial overall majority in Parliament it could do this. Parliament is supreme and sovereign.
It thus seems to me that there is no serious objection to the new Prime Ministers of Greece and Italy on grounds of a democratic deficit. We await with a great deal of interest the actions of the new governments. For the success or failure of Italy in particular will have repercussions for all of us, not just Italians.
Thursday, 10 November 2011
Is there a Euro Crisis?
One just cannot get away from the Euro and its woes. Not a day goes by without more talk of gloom and doom. Greece and Italy face the prospect of severe economic meltdown which could lead to an imminent break up of the Euro. There has even been talk that Greece might have to leave the EU, not just the Eurozone. Clearly something pretty bad is going on, but just how bad is it? In this post I want to try and clarify a couple of questions about this ongoing crisis. Not sure if I can come up with any answers.
There are two questions I find perplexing and rarely, if ever raised in the media. The first is why are the undoubted difficulties of Greece and Italy presented as a crisis for the Euro and the Eurozone? The second and related question is why has a crisis in private banking become a sovereign debt crisis?
As regards the first question, to get an idea of why all this talk of a crisis for the Euro is perplexing it may be useful to compare the situation in the Eurozone with the situation in the USA. Now the two are not directly comparable, but they do have in common that in each there is a single currency - the Dollar for the USA and the Euro for the Eurozone. There is also the fact that states in USA as in the Eurozone can get into financial difficulties, quite severe difficulties. However in the USA there is never any suggestion that financial problems in say, California, will cause anyone to question the survival of the Dollar. There is also no suggestion that California or any other state would be required to leave the USA.
Jacques Melitz, professor of economics at Heriot-Watt University in Einburgh has written an article about the lessons for the Euro from the USA. Talking about the situation in 2010, he writes: “The crisis brought about dire financing problems for many lower-level government units in the US and some national governments in the Eurozone. According to the spreads on credit default swaps, California and Illinois now have a higher probability of non-performance on public debt than Portugal and Spain. This has been true for months. Consider next the difference in response in the States and Europe. Recently Illinois simply stopped paying $5 billion of bills. In June of last year California issued vouchers for wage payments. In addition, savage cuts in public services have begun and are now threatened in various states in difficulty, not only these two. Nevada has made startling reductions in spending on higher education and welfare. “
So, in the USA when a state engages in irresponsible fiscal conduct it is the creditors and taxpayers who bear the brunt of the consequences. This is what was supposed to happen in the Eurozone. At its creation the ECB was explicitly forbidden to act as a lender of last resort and instead it was to be the financial markets that would ensure that member states kept to the true and narrow when it came to national debt. So why was Greece not just allowed to default way back in 2009? It could still be in the Eurozone, but it would have had to take very, very harsh measures to bring its public finances into order. Which it is having to do anyway. Oh, and there is also the small matter that creditors - the banks and other financial institutions - would have to take a full haircut on their loans. Not good for the banks.
What about Italy, the current country in the firing line? There are a couple of points to make here. One, though Italy’s national debt is pretty high at around 120% of GDP, it is not alone in this. Japan’s national debt represents 220% of its GDP! And yet Japan can borrow money at around 1%. Second point is that Italy is not remotely a basket case. As the Guardian usefully points out Italy is the eighth largest economy in the world and the fourth largest in Europe. Its gross domestic product (GDP) was over $2tn in 2010. Greece, Europe's other basket case, has a GDP of $305bn – an economy about the same size as Dallas, Fort Worth and Arlington in Texas. The Italian government clearly needs to implement some serious reforms which will no doubt be painful for lots of Italians. However the country can afford this. And it is surely a matter for Italians how they go about sharing the pain.
Daniel Gros, Director of the Centre for European Policy Studies, Brussels, has an interesting article entitled What is holding Italy back. His conclusion is that it is primarily the lack of good governance which is the biggest hindrance to economic growth. As he puts it: “This implies that it will be difficult to organise a sustained effort to combat corruption, foster adherence to the rule of law, and improve the efficiency of the administration in general. However, progress on these fronts might in the end be more important for growth than the reforms now being imposed by the EU.”
My second question was How has the crisis become a sovereign debt crisis instead of a banking crisis? For let us remember that this particular crisis originated way back in 2007 with the exposure of financial malpractice, irresponsibility and corruption by privately owned banks in Iceland, the UK, the USA and Ireland. Note also that only one of these countries, Ireland is in the Eurozone. Now one of the key virtues, supposedly, of capitalism and the free market is that there are winners and losers. Captains of finance get huge, some would say obscene rewards, but this is because they take huge risks. So, how come when it was time to take a loss, it was the taxpayers who had to step up to the plate? In most countries the big rise in government debt is primarily due to bailing out private banks. The ongoing saga of emergency loans to Greece, Ireland and Portugal is to prevent a default and the exposure of banks to meltdown. Why?
Why are all countries and this includes the so-called virtuous ones like Germany, Austria and Finland, so frightened of bank failures? After all the failure to tackle the root cause has already led to great suffering in Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain as a direct result of the harsh austerity measures. This will almost certainly spread to Italy very soon. However all these austerity measure just add to the downward pressure on the whole EU economies. Growth for the Eurozone in 2012 has been downgraded to 0.5%. This will have serious repercussions for Germany and the other so-called virtuous countries. The loss of exports to the rest of the Eurozone can only lead to higher unemployment in these countries. And all to prevent a collapse of private banks?
A collapse of the banking and financial sector would be pretty calamitous, but it would provide the basis for governments to nationalize the banks and ensure that they were brought under proper regulation and control. Finance is far too important to be left to bankers. It would also ensure that all countries shared in the pain of rebuilding a sound and sustainable economy.
Thursday, 3 November 2011
Greece and the Euro - What Next?
The drama of recent days continues unabated. As of this Thursday afternoon it looks like there will be no Greek referendum on the EU deal, but instead the main opposition party has agreed to support the deal in Parliament. Much relief all round, at least in Eurozone countries and in the UK government. It is far too early to know what will in fact happen and how this will develop over the coming days and weeks. But it is useful to step back a bit and try and figure out what is really behind all this turmoil.
In particular it would be helpful to get away from simplistic blame games. It is all the fault of Greece shout some, while others equally loudly yell that it is the nasty EU which is punishing the poor Greeks. It would also be good to disentangle the situation in Greece from the wider problems faced by the Euro.
In the case of Greece it is important to remember that the crisis facing that country is primarily due to the mismanagement of its public finances. The country faces deep seated problems which previous governments have avoided. It is to the credit of Papandreou and his current government that it is the first Greek government to face up to this reality and to begin to take measures to modernise the economy. This is something that Greece needs to do and there is no doubt that this will involve great suffering for many Greeks. However there is no real alternative. In passing it is worth pointing out that devaluation (leaving the Euro and going back to the Drachma) would make no difference to this. Unless a country takes the necessary steps to modernise its economy, devaluation makes no long term difference to a country.
The big problem for the country is that this particular challenge comes at the same time as the rest of the EU and most of the world is in the midst of a massive financial and economic crisis. The country has also been handicapped by the neo-liberal nonsense that currently passes for economic wisdom in most of the world. More and more austerity measures simply prolong the suffering of Greek people and postpone any recovery.
The EU and the European Central Bank (ECB) have however done nothing to help Greece. All this talk of Greek bailouts is just nonsense. The so-called bailouts are designed to bail out EU banks, in particular those in France, Germany and Belgium, which are most exposed to a Greek default. The EU lends money, at exorbitant interest rates, to the Greek government, to avoid a default. The money does not go to helping Greek people, who are suffering from cuts in wages and pensions and high unemployment. At the same time the EU and the IMF are forcing the Greek government to introduce even more drastic austerity measures, which can only lead to less growth in the economy and thus increase the likelihood of a Greek default.
This whole approach has of course clearly failed. The latest deal included a 50% loss for the banks. And most observers reckon that sooner or later Greece will have to default on the remaining 50%. It is all so depressing. The solution to the crisis, both in Greece and in the Eurozone as a whole is pretty clear. Greece needs to have its debt written off and have access to new funds at affordable interest rates. The country also needs to carry out fundamental reforms to its economy and public finances. But if this is to work this needs to happen in the context of a growing economy. Not just in Greece, but in the whole of the EU. Something similar needs to happen in other Eurozone countries. Not necessarily a write-off of debt, (Greece is the worst in this respect) but in access to funds at affordable interest rates.
This is not difficult to do. If the ECB were to act as a normal central bank, like the Bank of England or the Fed in the USA, that is to be a lender of last resort, then the core of the crisis would disappear. The ECB has the money, it can print as many Euros as it wants. If it announced that the ECB would buy Greek, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese and Irish government bonds at an announced interest rate, (a low one) then the markets would cease to speculate against these countries. Not only that, the ECB would probably not need to buy that many bonds. Once the market realised that the ECB was serious the various bondholders would return to the market. Where else are they going to put their money - under their pillows?
At the moment some EU countries are opposed to this, especially Germany, which because of its own history is still frightened of the dangers of inflation. However in the present economic climate inflation is not on the horizon and the real worry is the risk of a deep seated recession. There is also the problem of creating some kind of supranational governing body for the Eurozone. It seems the governments concerned have agreed to move towards this, but probably need to to do so quicker.
In many ways all this suffering in Greece and elsewhere is so unnecessary. The means are there to lessen the impact of reforms and to get the economy moving again. The lessons are there for all to see going back not just to the great depression in the twenties and thirties, but all the way back to the 1820s as Brad DeLong explains here. For more on the need for the ECB to act as a lender of last resort see here.
Thursday, 27 October 2011
Saving the Euro?
The recent EU summit meeting in Brussels has surprised most people. It looks like they have come up with a three point plan to save the Euro. And the immediate reaction of the markets has been very favourable. After months of wrangling and doing very little have our leaders finally lanced the boil of the financial crisis?
The short answer is no, but they seem to have come up with enough to pacify the markets for the time being. This involves a 50% haircut on Greek debt, a further recapitalisation of banks and an improved fund (the EFSF) to provide medium term support to Italy and Spain. The key words here are medium term. Let’s say until spring of next year. By then a lot more will need to be done.
Basically there are two immediate challenges for the Eurozone. The first is to get their own house in order to ensure that the likes of Spain and Italy are protected against further speculation. To this end the Eurozone countries need to come up with a credible plan and timetable for creating some kind of fiscal union. It need not be a full fiscal union as the USA, but it needs to be credible enough to satisfy the markets. They need to start work on this soon and we will need to know the outcome by early next year.
The other challenge facing the Eurozone, along with most of the rest of the world, is how to get their economies growing again. For example if Greece does not start to grow again very soon it will once again be unable to repay its national debt, even with the current 50% haircut. The same will apply to Italy and Spain. How this growth is to happen as long as the EU, including the UK, stick to harsher and harsher austerity measures is a bit of a mystery. Things are not looking good.
Monday, 27 June 2011
Will Greece have to default?
The answer to this is yes and it is only a matter of when, not if. At least that seems to be the view of most economists. At least those not employed by the EU, the ECB or the governments of the member states. It is easy to see why. Partly as a result of the austerity measures that the EU and IMF wish to inflict on Greece, there is simply no way in which the Greek economy can grow sufficiently to generate the funds to repay all these loans. Which of course makes it all the more likely that Greece will reject the proposals. Even if they are forced to accept them, the austerity measures, it merely delays the inevitable. At some stage in the not too distant future, Greece will have to default. And all hell is likely to break out.
The reason for this is that if Greece defaults then some of the big French and German banks will be in deep trouble. And the reason for this is that any kind of default or rescheduling of debts would force the banks to come clean on their losses. It is unlikely to end there, as a Greek default would almost certainly have a domino effect and lead to similar troubles in Ireland, Portugal and possibly Spain and Italy. To get an idea of how losses in Greece can affect banks elsewhere, please read this article by David Malone on his Golem XIV blog.
So the EU is desperate to keep Greece from defaulting, hence all the repayable loans it wants to force on the Greeks. Getting the already impoverished Greek taxpayers to bear the whole burden is quite cute, at least if you can get away with it. For remember, it is not in fact Greece that is getting bailed out, it is the bondholders, primarily the French and German banks who so recklessly leant the money to Greece in the first place.
However the likelihood is that by trying to stave off the inevitable, EU leaders are only making this worse in the long run. Preventing contagion spreading to Ireland and Portugal may be impossible due to current EU policy. Colm McCarthy, an Irish economist gives a good outline of how this failure to face up to the reality of a Greek default will make things worse, in this article for the Sunday Independent. He also makes the interesting point that this failure stems in part because, “European political leaders are reluctant to admit to their electorates that the euro system was poorly designed from the outset, that some countries should perhaps not have been admitted at all and that there have been massive failures of bank supervision. French banks apparently hold €56bn in Greek bonds, German banks €30bn. Why were they allowed to acquire these huge exposures?” It is just so much easier to blame poor feckless Greeks and gullible Irish.
So what is likely to happen? The smart money is on some kind of break-up of the Eurozone. Some of the peripheral countries will be forced out or voluntarily decide to leave the eurozone. This would come along with a default. While this would clear these countries’ sovereign debts, it is not clear what the long term consequences would be. The thinking behind this is that a much reduced eurozone - Germany, France, the Netherlands, Austria, Belgium - would not face the same strains and stresses of the current, wider zone. It would however still be faced with the same basic problem. Can a monetary union survive without a fiscal union? This would need the creation of European Finance ministry and would allow for fiscal transfers between member states. As is the case with the USA. While the current climate within the EU is hostile to such a move, perhaps within a core eurozone it might be easier to sell this plan to the electorates. Short of some kind of fiscal union the euro is likely to be doomed. As the creation of the euro was essentially a political decision, expect politics, especial the need to maintain the Franco German axis, to play a large part in any future decisions.
In the meantime, Europe needs to prepare for the worst. And this will alas include the UK. Since what we face is a solvency crisis, Europe needs to expunge the rot from its banks. This is the conclusion reached by John H Cochrane and Anil Kashyap, two professors of economics and finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business. In an article for the Wall Street Journal they highlight some of the key facts in this sorry Greek tragedy. Whatever the long term solution for the EU, some time soon, and the sooner the better, banks need to get their houses in order. As they put it, “Banks with inadequate capital must raise it, find buyers, or reorganize. If that means bailouts of ‘systematically important’ banks, then governments must do so, face their taxpayers, and make their regulators explain how they let this happen.”
I like that last bit, about making regulators explain how they let all this happen. I would go further and where possible charge them with gross dereliction of duty. At the very least they should no longer be employed as key government advisers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











